| # | Title | Artist | Rating | Length |
|---|
| A1 | Overture / A Very Proper Town | Tony Randall, Ensemble | | 6:23 |
| A2 | Life Does a Man a Favor (When It Gives Him Simple Joys) | Tony Randall, Jacquelyn McKeever | | 2:25 |
| A3 | Life Does a Man a Favor (When It Leads Him Down to the Sea) | Tony Randall, Crew | | 1:26 |
| A4 | Captain Henry St. James | Men’s Chorus | | 2:00 |
| A5 | Three Paradises | Tony Randall, Edward Platt | | 3:10 |
| A6 | Surprise | Jacquelyn McKeever, Ensemble | | 3:03 |
| A7 | Life Does a Man a Favor (When It Puts Him in Paree) / Hey Madame!- producer:
- Goddard Lieberson
- conductor:
- Jay Blackton (on 1958-02-09)
- vocals arranger:
- Jay Blackton
- orchestrator:
- Walter Eiger, Robert Ginzler, Joe Glover, Ray Jaimes, Oscar Kosarin, Philip J. Lang, Sy Oliver and Cornel Tanassy
- recorded at:
- Alvin Theatre in Manhattan, New York, New York, United States (on 1958-02-09)
- recording of:
- Hey, Madame! (on 1958-02-09)
- writer:
- Ray Evans and Jay Livingston
- part of:
- Oh Captain!
- recording of:
- Life Does a Man a Favor (When It Puts Him in Paree) (on 1958-02-09)
- writer:
- Ray Evans and Jay Livingston
- part of:
- Oh Captain!
| Tony Randall | | 1:50 |
| A8 | Femininity | Eileen Rodgers | | 2:41 |
| A9 | It’s Never Quite the Same | Edward Platt, Jacquelyn McKeever, Crew | | 4:23 |
| B1 | We’re Not Children | Paul Valentine, Jacquelyn McKeever | | 3:39 |
| B2 | Give It All You’ve Got / Love Is Hell | Susan Johnson, Ensemble | | 3:40 |
| B3 | Keep It Simple | Eileen Rodgers, Ensemble | | 1:56 |
| B4 | The Morning Music of Montmartre | Susan Johnson, Ensemble | | 2:47 |
| B5 | You Don’t Know Him | Jacquelyn McKeever, Eileen Rodgers | | 4:40 |
| B6 | I’ve Been There and I’m Back | Tony Randall, Edward Platt | | 3:24 |
| B7 | Double Standard | Jacquelyn McKeever, Eileen Rodgers | | 2:15 |
| B8 | You’re So Right for Me | Edward Platt, Eileen Rodgers | | 2:58 |
| B9 | All the Time | Tony Randall, Jacquelyn McKeever | | 2:09 |
| B10 | Finale | Ensemble | | 0:57 |